
Charles Darwin - photo from Bettmann Archive
Until this past weekend, I had never heard of an “evolutionist“.
Sure, I realized that many – perhaps most – of my immediate community don’t believe in evolution. I also realized that creationists’ views are given more deference by Texas schools than I would like. Beyond that, I had not really considered the creationists’ perceptions.
Then I read the Lubbock paper on Saturday along with my migas and coffee.
Cal Thomas‘ column that day, representing “the right’ was about stem cell research. While making his argument, he was pretty vehement about this whole “evolutionist” thing, and it was clear that he was probably talking about me. And it was clear that his perception of me and people like me wasn’t good.
As in next-step-to-Nazism-and-slave-holding not good. He sniffed: “Appeals to the uniqueness of human life are likely to fall on deaf ears if you are an evolutionist.”
Yeah, us evolutionist sciencey-types are too busy building Frankenstein monsters out of corpses in our basements to care about the uniqueness of human life. Or maybe we’re off somewhere practicing up on our Nazi skills. No wait – that’s some Rich Iott guy; I’m pretty sure that he’s a Creationist though I couldn’t verify that on the inter-webs. Anyway, it was clear what Cal Thomas meant in his column.
His logic went something like this: Embryonic stem cell research uses embryonic cells. Using embryonic stem cells is bad because each human life is unique. Scientists came up with the idea to use embryonic stem cells. Scientists believe in evolution. Evolution is bad. Because it came from scientists, not from God. Therefore, scientists and anyone who believes in embryonic stem cells/ evolution or who is friends with an actual scientist is in danger of either a)starting the next holocaust or b) becoming slave owners.
I’m the daughter of a high school biology teacher who is also a life-long Baptist. Growing up, my Daddy told me that God was powerful enough to have used evolution as his tool to create the Earth. That seemed pretty logical to me. I’ve gone all these years without knowing that my dad’s logic makes us “theistic evolutionists”.
Using the word “evolutionist” seems to denote, in a sort of code to the hard-core religious right, that a person is a heathen. They don’t care whether we’re “theistic” or “naturalistic” evolutionists.
On the other hand, I don’t think that most scientists refer to themselves as “evolutionists” at all; in fact, I doubt that most lay people who believe in evolution have ever even heard the term.
The word “evolutionist” emphasizes the idea that evolution is “just a theory“, which doesn’t go along with the scientific understanding of evolution at all. Using the term “evolutionist” effectively portrays those who believe in the scientific fact of evolution as members of a religion – a religion that is not mainstream.
Of course, being “not mainstream” in the United States of America these days is not so good.
Evolution is a god-sent gift to those who would wage the culture war, pun intended. Those of us who believe in evolution take it for granted as common knowledge until some nutjob tries to take the teaching of evolution out of a text book.
Meanwhile, creationists are gaining ground in the United States, with a 2010 poll of the US, Britain and Canada showing that in the US only 35% of people polled accepted evolution as fact compared to over 60% of respondents in the other two countries. (The US also had an 18% “undecided” group.)
In reality, just as in the right-wing creationist propaganda, the truth of evolution is beginning to be outside the mainstream - unpopular, not the leading opinion.
Scientists believed that the decision to teach evolution was made once and for all back in the 1960′s when we were in a science race with the Russians. Unfortunately, unless we want our children to be taught that dinosaurs roamed the earth alongside humans, those of us who value reason and science – both the theists and the naturalists among us – are going to have to grasp that this particular battle in the culture war is on again.
Note: This post also appears on my Open Salon blog.